Appeal to establish a public inquiry into the assassination of Ms. Daphne Caruana Galizia

Dear Prime Minister Joseph Muscat,

I write to you on behalf of the European Centre for Press and Media Freedom and 22 organisations (listed below) representing thousands of journalists and human rights activists concerning Malta’s response to the assassination of journalist Ms Daphne Caruana Galizia.

Following her murder on 16 October 2017, the Maltese authorities initiated criminal proceedings against the men who allegedly detonated the bomb that killed Ms Caruana Galizia and a parallel magisterial inquiry into whether others should be charged with criminal offences for commissioning the alleged assassins. Both the criminal proceedings and magisterial inquiry focus solely on criminal culpability.

Neither process is investigating the wider and even more serious question as to whether the Maltese state is responsible for the circumstances that led to Ms Caruana Galizia’s death.

Article 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights requires Malta – as a Member State of the Council of Europe – to comply with its protective obligation by examining (a) whether Malta knew, or ought to have known, of a real and immediate risk to Ms Caruana Galizia’s life; (b) the adequacy of any steps taken by Malta to guard against that risk; and (c) any steps that Malta needs to take to prevent future deaths of journalists and/or anti-corruption campaigners.

On 9 August 2018, a team of international lawyers from Doughty Street Chambers and Bhatt Murphy Solicitors in London issued a legal opinion finding that Malta has failed to institute any inquiry into whether the Maltese state bears any responsibility for the loss of Ms Caruana Galizia’s life. Following the legal opinion, the family has submitted the following request to your government:

To establish a public inquiry under the Inquiries Act that is completely independent of the Maltese police, Government and politicians, and that is conducted by a panel of respected international judges, retired judges and/or suitably qualified individuals with no political or government links.

We fully support the request and urge you to reconsider your position and to respond immediately and positively to the request of the family of Ms Caruana Galizia.

Protecting the lives and voices of journalists in Malta and across Europe depends upon this public inquiry. There is nothing to fear from this inquiry but the truth.

Seeking justice for Ms Caruana Galizia and protection for those who continue her legacy remains our top priority.

We would appreciate your written response to our appeal.

Flutura Kusari, Legal Advisor, The European Centre for Press and Media Freedom.

List of Organisations

Access Info

Active Watch

aditus foundation

Article 21

Blueprint for Free Speech

Committee to Protect Journalists

European Federation of Journalists

Global Editors Network

Helsinki Foundation for Human Rights

IFEX (the global network of over 100 freedom of expression organizations)

Index on Censorship

Integra Foundation

International Press Institute

OBC Transeuropa/ Centro per la Cooperazione Internazionale

Ossigeno per l’Informazione

PEN International

PEN America

Platform of Human Rights Organisations in Malta (PHROM)

Press Emblem Campaign

Reporters Without Borders (RSF)

South East Europe Media Organisation

Transparency International

The Critical Institute

The European Centre for Press and Media Freedom

The World Association of Newspapers and News Publishers (WAN-IFRA)

The Minister needs to confirm that Malta is still a safe and functioning democracy. NGO Statement on recent Ministerial actions on the ‘Daphne Memorial’

The actions of the Ministry for Justice, Culture and Local Government in relation to the ‘Daphne Memorial’ in Valletta are utterly shameful and reprehensible. They represent an unequivocal repression of free and peaceful political and personal expression. These are fundamental human rights boldly enshrined in Malta’s Constitution and part of the human rights regime Malta so proudly subscribes to.

The Government’s, or the Minister’s, opinions of slain journalist Daphne Caruana Galizia should play absolutely no part in its relationship with a group of people who, on a regular basis, choose to gather in Valletta to express political opinions or to mourn Daphne Caruana Galizia.

International and national human rights law protect the rights of all people in Malta to assemble, and to express their opinions. These are core pillars of a functioning democracy, since they ensure the safety of people whose personal, political, religious or other views – and their public expression – jar with those of the majority, and of the government. Limitations on these rights are only permitted where strictly necessary and for reasons linked to the protection of national security, public safety or the rights of others.

The Ministry’s justification for its actions – to safeguard national monuments – is therefore unacceptable and a clear populist attempt at ignoring basic legal standards, especially since no damage to the Great Siege Monument was ever alleged or demonstrated. Furthermore, the Ministry may comfortably rely on other less intrusive laws for the protection of our national heritage, without acting in such a repressive and childish manner.

We therefore urge the Minister for Justice, Culture and Local Government to immediately refrain from these undemocratic tactics and to simply allow the public and peaceful demonstration of opinions and views that he might not be comfortable with.

This is not asking for too much, just for the peace of mind that we still live in a safe and functioning democracy,

Dr. Neil Falzon (aditus foundation Director).

“You cannot call for the national unity you all demolished!”

NGO Statement on the assassination of Daphne Caruana Galizia

We are extremely distressed at the national situation that has led to, permitted or even encouraged the brutal assassination of Daphne Caruana Galizia. Monday’s abominable act was not committed in a social or political vacuum but as a result of the culture of hatred, division, bigotry and opportunism that successive Maltese Governments and Parliaments have fuelled and thrived on.

The concerns we expressed earlier this year (The nation deserves better, and more, from Government and Parliament) are today more urgent and relevant than ever before. Whilst it is imperative to unmask and bring to justice all the perpetrators of Daphne’s assassination, it is just as crucial to unreservedly denounce all other guilty parties, all those whose actions cumulatively took her life and – at the same time – stripped the nation of its sense of freedom, security and well-being.

Every insult uttered and written against her, every attack on her credibility and integrity, every law suit instituted against her, every garnishee order attacking her assets, and every act of bullying and intimidation only served to generate unprecedented volumes of community hatred against one person, one journalist. It is extremely worrying that these volumes of hatred and social divide have been carefully assembled and fortified by the two main political parties, who over decades have successfully fragmented Maltese society with impunity.

aditus has on many occasions deplored the language of hatred used by parliamentarians, public servants and politicians against people who are of different a political belief, gender, colour or sexual orientation. It has also condemned the unacceptable lack of sanctions and accountability that followed such incidences.

The dishing out of public positions, public contracts and public funds to friends, family members and political sympathisers has led to a gradual yet extremely effective weakening of the democratic institutions intended to preserve the rule of law, accountability and transparency. In 2017, crucial pillars of a democratic state, the Malta Police Force and the Judiciary no longer enjoy the respect of the public and autonomy needed to fulfil their roles.

Other monitoring bodies, including the Office of the Ombudsman and the National Commission for the Promotion of Equality have not been provided with the necessary power to keep abuse, cronyism and illegal practices in check.

The above has been acerbated by complacency and an establishment of an educational system that is utterly devoid of active citizenship values, that ignores the value of critical thinking and that seeks conformity as opposed to individuality. By building the environment for such hatred to flourish, and then annihilating the very structures intended to protect us all from acts of hatred, a relatively small group of people have not only thrown Malta into democratic and constitutional chaos but are now complicit in Malta’s most heinous crime.

Finally, we are astounded by the lack of serious collective mourning by all public institutions – including the Office of the President, Ministers, the House of Representatives and the Judiciary – in the face of such a barbaric attack on an individual, on press freedom and on civil society.

The human rights values that aditus foundation promotes and seeks to protect speak of unity, harmony, and mutual understanding despite political, ethnic, gender and other differences. Human rights strengthen people and empower them to become active and fulfilled individuals.

Human rights also bolster communities and nations by providing the social and structural tools necessary to foster safety and security, such as independent and impartial courts of law, inclusive social support systems, equality bodies, effective police forces, and a thriving civil society.

With this spirit, we will be attending the civil society event ĠUSTIZZJA on SUNDAY 22 OCTOBER at 16.00, before the House of Representatives (Valletta), and invite you all to join us.

#maltaunderthreat as activist blogger is brutally assassinated: joint NGO statement

MGRM, aditus Foundation, Integra Foundation, the Critical Institute and the Platform of Human Rights Organisation in Malta extend their condolences to the family of Daphne Caruana Galizia and express their concern at the threat to freedom of speech that her violent murder poses.

We urge the government to ensure that law enforcement are adequately resourced to conduct the necessary investigations and to do all in their power to bring those responsible to justice.

Given that it has been reported that in the past days Daphne Caruana Galizia reported threats on her life, we also request an independent inquiry into whether the police took the requisite measures to protect the victim and whether this outcome could have been averted.